View Single Post
Old 16-03-02, 10:52 AM   #2
snowman
Registered User
 
Join Date: Mar 2002
Posts: 56
yayaya never going to work!!

Basic cryptology 101 tells you that as long as the source document is available in any plain text open format such as:

a) WAV format as on a CD, or
b) Analog audio as in a AM/FM radio, or
c) RF signal on a stereo/player/recorder patch cable, or
d) audio spectrum as in live concert that we can hear,

encryption to restrict access of the music is useless.

Simply use the unencrypted version to read or play the message and ignore the encrypted one. Is this not obvious or what?

The American DMCA protects encrypted or copy protected or restricted access to music and video performances however I do believe that to prove that it was accessed in a way that circumvents the protection the copyright holder has to prove that the original was "secret" and not in general circulation.

This is going to be akin to a 007 type encrypting a secret message for his/her masters, sending the secret version by a 100 gazillion dollar satellite communication system then e-mailing the real message in plain text to every P2P, FTP server, usersgroup, mail list on the planet and by snail mail to every CD sales store in the universe. Is this not why acts play gig's?

Why bother.

Encryption is only valid if there is a limited and controlled distribution of the plain text message.

In the case of music where the primary goal is to get people like you and me to listen to as a public performance it is rather useless.

If it had value then the CD's and DVD's would of had a 2048 bit encryption system on them from the start.
__________________
snow man
snowman is offline   Reply With Quote