View Single Post
Old 29-01-02, 02:20 PM   #7
TankGirl
Madame Comrade
 
TankGirl's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2000
Location: Area 25
Posts: 5,587
Wink Re: Strange bitrates are usually tip-off for VBR files

Quote:
Originally posted by Stoepsel
And if you think about it, what bitrate SHOULD a client report when dealing with VBR files? There's not much else that would make sense...
That's a good point. Even with CBR a high bitrate is not a guarantee of good quality as much depends on the decoder being used but with VBR there are many more variables... I myself would think that highest bitrate being used would be more indicative than the average bitrate of the frames.

If I remember correctly the Nap/OpenNap protocol uses just a single number for bitrate and there is no extra parameter to indicate whether it is CBR/VBR (correct me if I am wrong). Perhaps if you have a VBR with 192 kbs as top bitrate, the client should report it as 191, similarly 256 VBR could be reported as 255. This practice would make a good use of the single figure available...

- tg

ps. Welcome to the board Stoepsel!
TankGirl is offline   Reply With Quote